Henry Thornton Home Page
"Don't talk to me about naval tradition. It is nothing but rum, sodomy and the lash." Winston Churchill
Louis Hissink
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email

Gary Scarrabelotti
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email

PD Jonson
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email

Nick Raffan
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email

Henry Thornton
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email

Reader Submissions
Articles Articles
Comments Comment
Email Me Email
Henry Thornton - Contributors: A discussion of economic, social and political issues Blogs
Central banks to the rescue, but urgent problems remain
Date: Friday, September 16, 2011
Author: Henry Thornton

Leading central banks have agreed to pump US dollars into Eurozone markets, helping to produce a fourth day of gains to global equity markets.

(The banks involved are The European Central Bank, the US Federal Reserve, the Bank of England, the Bank of Japan and the Swiss National Bank, clearly a serious mob.)

A first sign of US goods and services inflation was ignored amid the general euphoria, as was an increase of initial claims for unemployment benefits and more evidence of weak manufacturing activity.

Debate continues to rage about the future of the Eurozone, with Anatole Kaletsky presenting a varient of Professor Alan Meltzer's notion discussed here yesterday. Kaletsky suggests that Germany (rather than a group of strong Eurozone countries as in Meltzer's plan) leave the Euro, allowing a defacto devaluation of other Euro currencies but without the risk of bank failure that would be inevitable if Greece leaves, followed by other weak nations. (Kaletsky's views are in today's Australian newspaper, but again without a link, like Meltzer's yesterday)

Ambrose Evans-Pritchard reports from the World Economic Forum meeting in Dalian

"This is the most urgent crisis facing the world today," said Zhu Min, the IMF's deputy managing director and China's voice at the institution.

"There is no room for politicians to muddle through: they have to take decisive action today. Banks must be recapitalised and made solvent."

In distant Australia, Henry has purchased some out-of-the-money puts in case the whole Euromess trashes equity markets. Meanwhile, politicians continue to trade abuse and to argue about items on the traditional pinhead.

However, the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) has galloped (well, plodded actually) to the gummint's rescue by redefining the contents of the 'basket' of goods and services in the consumer price index to suggest inflation is less of a threat.

Treasurer Wayne Swan has removed from the 'independent' Reserve Bank the right to set the governor's salary.  Apparently he learned of Glenn Stevens' million dollar plus salary only 18 months after the event, via the RBA's annual report.

If this is true, it almost defies reason because of the risk to a climate of low wage inflation that it posed. If Treasurer, most of us would expect it to be at least mentioned by the gov'nor in one of his regular chats. After-all the Treasurer is the representative of the parliament to whom Mr Stevens is ultimately responsible, despite the 'independence' notionally granted to the RBA by means of an exchange of letters.  The Reserve Bank Act, which defines the relationship of the RBA and the people of Australia, makes it clear just who prevails in any conflict.

Former governor Bernie Fraser was on ABC radio defending (weakly Henry thought) the governor's salary, but Henry's sources say Bernie himself turned down similar largesse in his time, as reported here. (See the May 23 2011 entry of the author's Blog at GreatCrisesofCapitalism.com.)

If 'independent' salary setting can be removed at the stroke of a pen, so too can 'independent' decision making, and it would be one sure-fire way to get the Aussie dollar to depreciate.

Take care, Glenn Stevens. Mention of how much you give to charity each year (assuming it is quite a lot) might be wise about now.

Saturday Sanity Break, 21 February 2015
Date: Saturday, February 21, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

The event of the year for Henry is the advent of a new book by Geoffrey Blainey. Its arrival is celebrated in the weekend's Australian Magazine where Geoffrey explains ways in which he sees parts of Australian history with fresh eyes. This article covers largely the history of the first Australians and a theme is that 'Aborigines experienced what is surely the most significant event in our history. Nothing since 1788 can compare in magnitude to the great rising of the seas which – in full sight of scores of generations of coastal Aborigines – flooded coastal plains and valleys. It severed Australia from New Guinea in the north and Tasmania in the south'.

Professor Blainey adds that: 'In comparison, the rise in sea levels and the global warming currently predicted for the next 100 years seem like a sideshow. It is a triumph of the human spirit that Aborigines as a people survived an event which must slowly have drowned all or part of the homeland of perhaps one in every three tribes or “nations”.'

The concluding paragraphs comment on the so-called 'history wars' and follow with a nice remembered account: 'Controversy, not war, will continue for a long time to come. It is in the nature of history and of most intellectual activities, and the more so in a nation where the main strands of history – Aboriginal and European – are utterly different.

'In 1948 I was in the public gallery of the old parliament house in Canberra. There I looked down with a sense of wonder at the oldest member, the silver-haired Billy Hughes, who had been a member of the first federal parliament in 1901. I did not then know that in parliament he had often sat near William Groom, a senior Queensland politician who, as a 13-year-old back in the 1840s, had been transported as a convict to Australia.

'It shows the brevity of [conventional, post 1788] “Australian history’” that through good fortune I was able to see a living politician whose parliamentary colleague belonged to the convict era – the time when the first settlement at Sydney began. In contrast, the indigenous history of this country is unimaginably long'.

Read on here.

Professor Geoffrey Blainey’s The Story of Australia’s People: Volume I (Viking, $49.99) will be available in the best bookshops on Wednesday.

Political economy

Australia's latest blood sport, Abbott bashing, continues unabated, with even the senior journos throwing some punches, including stories that I find literally incredible, such as the allegation that Chief-of-staff Peta Credlin sometimes chaired the Expenditure Review Committee. 

But there is so much acrid smoke that one must assume that there are plenty of smoldering ashes. Even friends of Tony Abbott say they fear he will not survive for long.

In matters economic, Henry must say, with a heavy heart, that the budget is buggered, and that only drastic action will stave off recession.  Conventional budget reform would involve cutting expenditure or raising taxes, or some mix of the two. Such action is necessary to fix the budget and stop the rise of debt. This will almost certainly slow or delay recovery of the economy unless ...

... Budget reform is accompanied by bold action to encourage growth.

Nick Greiner in today's AFR says there is a need for a "grand compromise" to end the budget stand-off or risk the country grinding slowly toward a "train wreck".

Hear, hear to that, but simply cutting spending and raising taxes - the traditional Treasury way - will be deflationary unless positive energy is injected via serious economic reform.

Here is Henry's agenda for reform.


Fiona Prior falls under the spell of Graeme Murphy's Swan Lake


Wild storms have wreaked havoc in the deep north, and we sincerely hope people are safe and that the insurance companies do not play too hard in assessing the claims that are sure to be many. Rebuliding will add to economic activity and may provide a boost that helps the economy.  It is not a boost that John Maynard Keynes would salute, even though in a satirical moment he proposed digging holes and filling them in again.

At the time of writing, Australia's game with Bangladesh is likely to be truncated or called off.  With the minimun 20 overs each, anything could happen, and the Bangladashies (sic?) are sure to have noted how Brandan McCallum or David Warner make runs. Meanwhile, England seem disinterested, being flogged by New Zealand who are emerging as a real chance to win the tournement.

The footy season is somewhat delayed by the cricket but Essendon continues to hog the limelight. They have been granted permission to patch together a team, sadly not including men from the Ascot Vale firsts, and should get flogged until their regular players are allowed back.

What sad news it was that code-hopper Karmicheal Hunt has been charged with drug using and drug peddling. At least it was not in Indonesia, so he will not face a firing squad, but his new Rugby career seems likely to be over.

Recession or Reform
Date: Thursday, February 19, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

Gor blimey, comrades, Messrs Abbott and Hockey are singing from the same hymn sheet and the subject is hell and damnation.

Tony Abbott pointed out, entirely reasonably I hasten to add, that Australia's massive budget deficits and rising debt was stealing from our children, and their children.

Today Joe Hockey has weighed in with some powerful rhetoric of his own, as reported by Adam Creighton.

* 'Speaking to business owners of the Sydney Business Chamber, Joe Hockey said the forthcoming Intergenerational Report – a five-yearly document looking at long term fiscal pressures, due for release soon – would make Australians “fall off their chairs”.

* 'But he said the Intergenerational Report would “stimulate a conversation” about whether the rules around superannuation were sustainable for the long term.

* 'Mr Hockey said the IGR would not be like past reports but “a very genuine attempt by the Treasury, in an unprecedented way, to launch a conversation about Australia’s future”.'

RBA Chief Glenn Stevens recently told the pollies that the debt and deficit situation could get far worse 'in a heartbeat'.

And the ratings agency S&P today put the cherry on the top by warning that Australia's AAA credit rating could be put at risk, meaning we'd have to pay more in interest on that debt.

This is Banana Republic Redux. The original Banana Republic was postponed by tough fiscal and wage policies by the Hawke-Keating government, then the recession it (and all of us 'punters') had to have, further postponed by the Howard-Costello government's reforms and seemingly banished by the mother of resource booms.

But motherly booms always end in busts, and the current bust has revealed the dodgy underpinnings of Australia's so-called 'miracle economy'.

Comrades, we know what is needed.  Without imagination and courage, austerity measures which all Australians except the real battlers embrace willingly will be needed. But the measures of austerity must be fair, and be seen to be fair.

'Here is the thing' as a young man might put it.  Without imagination, there are two roads to redemption.  Cut spending and hold it down until the budget disaster and lack of competitiveness is fixed.  Or raise taxes.  Or some mix of the two.

If handled badly, and perhaps even if fiscal reform is handled well, we shall experience the recession we did not need to have.  It is 18 months since this warning was offered, and perhaps too late to avoid recession. 

The best chance of avoiding recession involves a burst of economic reform to create growth that would help the budget and create jobs. When ratios to GDP are out of whack, a government can cut the denominator or raise the numerator.

Here are eight big ideas to raise the numerator, with the full analysis available here.

* Immediate action needs to be taken to reverse cabotage rules introduced since 2009, and phase out as rapidly as possible the entire cabotage system and its unique work practices regime. This would allow costal shipments of products and raw materials to be transported at internationally competitive rates.

* High efficiency super-critical coal fired power generation must become again the major base for a return to Australia’s power and energy cost advantage, even if we eventually decide Australia is ready for nuclear alternatives.

* Company tax reform needs to provide for the write-off of new manufacturing equipment to match overseas competitors.

* Government should urgently remove regulatory impediments to management and labour flexibility, to allow work practices and conditions of employment to be tailored to the specific needs of each individual business.

* Policies need to be put in place to raise the overall spend (Government and corporate) on R&D as a percentage of GDP, to global best practice levels. The program would need to ensure that relevant business and administrative skills and experience are available to use any Government support effectively. The government's new 'Growth Centres are relevant here, as is the long-standing CRC Program.

*  A task force needs to be constituted to review best practice arrangements in countries which lead the table of performance with innovation and commercialisation. The outcome would be a basis to review and implement policies which would be relevant for Australia, which currently is the lowest county in the OECD rankings in this vital area.

* A persistently overvalued exchange rate is a form of asset pricing imbalance that involves instability of industry structure and which requires fresh thinking by the Reserve Bank of Australia.

* Priority be given to mergers which favour the formation of a strong group which can compete in international markets rather than having weak fragmented entities. The ACCC brief needs appropriate revision.

It is very late if recession is to be avoided.  But better late than never, as Grandma Thornton used say.  Radical economic reform requires both courage and imagination.

We shall soon find out if our leaders have what it takes.

The coming global property bubble
Date: Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

'KEEP interest rates low for long enough and the property market will eventually boom' asserts Buttonwood of the Economist. 'That has been a good rule of thumb for investors throughout history. It is even proving true in Europe, despite the continent’s sluggish economy'.

There you have it, dear readers, a similar view to Henry's, as presented last week.  Henry's graphic hints of a focus on housing, reflecting the traditional Aussie bias.  But the basic logic is similar to Buttonwood's far more sophisticated offering.

The venerable mag summarises, and offers an entirely rational explanation. 'Europe’s rebound outpaced the 9% rise in global property transactions, although not a 15% rise in American deals. Office buildings and hotels were the most active sectors worldwide.

'It is hardly surprising that investors are enthusiastic for bricks and mortar. In both the cash and government-bond markets, yields are zero or even negative. By comparison, yields of 5% on American property or even 4% on office blocks in central London look attractive'.

Yields on property are falling, but long-term returns from property look very respectable. 'In the ten years to end-September, American commercial property delivered a total annualised return of 7.9%, according to IPD, a property-information group; returns in both Canada and New Zealand were in the double digits over the same period (see chart). That compares with the 8.1% annual return (including dividends) achieved by American equities over the same period and with the 6.8% annual return achieved on long-term Treasury bonds'.

Is the market due for another downturn? 'Not necessarily. Property is vulnerable to three things: a rise in interest rates, a downturn in the economy that hits demand, and a burst of speculative building that leads to oversupply.

* 'On the first point, central banks are still cutting rates in much of the world. There is the possibility of rate rises in America and Britain over the next year, but with inflation very low, central banks are likely to be cautious.

* Second, 'The world economy is not exactly racing, but forecasts (for what they are worth) predict GDP growth of more than 1% in the euro area and Japan and more than 3% in America. In any case, prime properties, which investors are most enthusiastic about, managed to weather the 2008-09 recession and so should be resilient to another downturn.

* 'In terms of supply, it is easy to be misled by the view from The Economist's offices of the flocks of cranes perched over London. This is the exception. Globally there is yet to be the kind of development spree that usually marks the peak of the property cycle. Deals involving development land fell by 29% globally last year, including a 3% decline in Europe'. Trevor Swan, one of Australia's few globally significent economists, once advised the young Henry that the may cranes of Sydney had stopped moving. 'That's all you need to observe to see the recession has started' the old boy (as he then was) announced.

The cranes of London are still moving, and elseware they are like the famous parrot - not dead but resting. 'So it is possible that commercial property’s streak could last a good deal longer. Lots of investors need income and the obvious alternative to property—corporate bonds—has had a very good run. Investors have even been willing to accept a negative yield on bonds issued by Nestlé, a Swiss foods group, in effect paying for the privilege of lending it money.

'Until the 1970s property was the asset of choice for long-term investors such as university endowments and pension funds. It has been replaced in recent decades by government bonds, which are much more liquid. If yields on bonds stay at Japan-like levels for a while, however, the allure of property will only increase. And if inflation returns, property will be a better hedge than conventional government bonds'.

And in conclusion: 'Eventually, such logic will inflate a bubble, of course. Residential property in London (fuelled by a combination of low rates and international capital) has already reached that point. But the surge of interest in second-tier and more speculative commercial-property projects that marks the top of the cycle is only just beginning, at least in Europe. The skyscrapers will tell you when to worry'.

Sunday Sanity Break, 15 February 2015
Date: Sunday, February 15, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

The new year is already looking like the old year.  Henry's corporate commitments are still limbering up and his major research project is on hold and so there has been time to listen to or even watch the antics in the hig house on capitol hill. We have been slowed up by a serious carpel tunnel problem that fortunately was fixed in time to avoid real problems.  While in recovery mode - NO TYPING - there has been almost enforced Skye News watching. Parliament seems more than ever like a public school where the boys have taken over and the headmistress is trying unsucessfully to rule the roost from her podium in the Assembly Hall. The rules remain absolutely no generosity of spirit, no sense of common purpose and no common courtesy is to be shown by either side.

As well as watching (and seething with frustration) I have at least found time to produce a few blogs. As is my wont these include comment on monetary policy ahead of the RBA board meeting and afterwards. My strong advice ahead of the meeting was that the economy needed the budget to be fixed as well as policies to make Australia more efficient and competitive. There was little justification for further cuts to monetary policy, unless the economy was in deeper trouble than senior members of the government, or for that matter the RBA, had indicated.  And there was a real chance of renewing, or strengthening, the housing boom, although the RBA may be relying on APRA to impose new-fangled 'macroprudential policy' to sort that problem.

The view that there was little case for further rate cuts was of course trumped by the RBA Chief with a rate cut.  Many will say that the RBA is looking good in the light of the large jump in the official (ABS) unemployment rate data released today. The RBA forecasts were shaded, not slashed, however, so it is reasonable to ask why the RBA has changed tack. (This is discussed in my latest blog, linked here.  This blog also touches on the touchy subject of pre-meeting 'briefing' by the RBA, which it has been asserted was especially obvious before this latest meeting of the board.

The weekend AFR reports that Glenn Stevens has said to a meeting of parlimentarians that the budget problem could get much worse 'in a heartbeat'.  If they were not terrified, they should be.

Gov'nor Glenn also said there is a limit to what monetary policy can do. This was because interest rates are already low, but a far bigger issue is that other policies, concerning regulation, fiscal policy and policies of state and local government have far more impact on the economy than a small cut (or cuts) in rates of interest.  I am sure that Glenn Stevens agrees with this, but no doubt thinks the RBA has to be seen to be doing its bit. But rate cuts will be positively unhelpful if they stimulate asset inflation.  Initial impacts suggest this is a real risk.

Art lovers may care to comment on my editor's latest post-modern painting, designed to illustrate that monetary ease in current circumstances goes more reliably into asset prices than economic stimulus.

All of Henry's friends bemoan the state of Australian politics and ask what can be done. In 'Political economy, Aussie style' I provide an answer. A reader asked if I was advocating policy made by technocrats rather than politicians. I remarked that the independant central bank with a clear mandate had served Australia well.

While giving Treasury independance plus a mandate to run a sensible fiscal policy is probably a bridge too far, what about requiring Treasury to provide us all with its policy advice, as the RBA does in its field.

This is worth debate and, when it bobs up in a newspaper, please recall you heard it first here.

All the best for the year ahead. Remember this is a time to tread carefully with seatbelt engaged.


Fiona Prior is back, reviewing Cirque de Soleil. She says, for those of Henry’s [mostly elderly] readers 'whose idea of a circus is a ringmaster, elephants, and men with whips facing off giant cats – Cirque de Soleil is a completely different experience altogether (except, maybe, for a shared penchant for sparkly leotards)'.

You must not miss this, elderly readers.  It will help you to look cool to your grandchildren.

Henry judges that this summer's movies are the best for years. The latest stunner is Selma, the story of the freedon marches in Alabama several short decades ago.

Hard to accept that back then American Negroes, as African Americans were called, were blocked from voting, a century after the Civil War. Lovely work by all concerned, and here is a trailer. Watch the ad, Shen Yen, 5000 years of Chinese history in one gorgous sitting.


Australia beat England by 111 runs in the second match of the World Cup of Cricket.  This was despite batting failures by Warner, Watson and Smith and with Mitch

Marsh getting five for while Johnson and Starc dealt gently with the pestiferous poms (PPs)  Smith chimed in with the best catch I have seen, and Starc pulled of a close second miracle catch. George Bailey scored 55 and captained the team well. Sadly, Bailey may be required to stand down in favour of Michael Clark, which seems like a real pity.

As predicted here last weekend, it seems that Essendon will be 'topped up' with a team mainly from Ascot Vale and other suburban teams.  Hope a suburban coach is in charge of the team, not Sir James Hird - did you miss Tony's latest cap'ns choice? Imagine the furore if Essendon Vale beat an AFL heavyweight, like Collingwood.

With cricket on for 6 weeks, by which time the footy will be underway, there will not be much time for moping, or trying to help Tony save his job.  Some honest toil, that's what we both need, like choppimg trees or weeding vegetable patches.

Image of the week

Courtesy The Oz

Rate cut - Asset inflation or economic boost?
Date: Tuesday, February 10, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

The RBA's latest excellent summary of the world and local economies, and the implications for monetary policy, was made available on Friday.  One could not assume that the timing was designed to distract us all from the political hi-jinks, but if it was it failed.  But now we are back to business as normal it is only fair to devote serious attention to the excellent work of the men and women of  the RBA's economic department.

Key questions remain. Resuming the policy easing may provide some boosts to non-mining activity and some assistance to a lower exchange rate.  But what if it fuels further housing inflation, as initial responses suggests is likely?  Will APRA's untested 'macroprudential policy' be able to prevent a housing boom turning into a bubble?

First we summarise the latest Monetary Statement. I shall use a staccato presentation of main facts.  In short:

* Growth slowed a bit in Asia - China, Japan, East Asia.

* Growth increased in USA.

* Price of oil fell further.

* Price of other commodities fell, but a bit slower rate.

* Net effect: 'Australia’s MTP growth is expected to continue at around its pace of recent years in 2015 as a number of effects offset each other'. [Sadly, 'MTP' is not something I have encountered before, which confession will strengthen the general view in Henry's household that the old boy is past it.]

* The oil price falls are putting downward pressure on global prices of goods and services. The dread word 'deflation' is being discussed in hushed tones in central banking land, especially in the ECB.

* Central banks have eased - 'QE' in Europe, rate cuts elsewhere, financial markets have pushed back expectations of rate hikes in the USA. 'Sovereign bond yields in the major markets have fallen significantly, particularly at longer maturities, although the size of the decline in yields is difficult to explain' [Ouch, if the RBA is puzzled, Henry is absolutely baffled.]

* Here is a zinger: 'The increasingly divergent paths of monetary policy among the major advanced economies have led to some sizeable movements in exchange rates'. The Swiss Franc moved dramatically after the Swiss abandoned policy of holding their currency down, and US dollar rising against most others, as next move in US rates is expected to be up.  The  so-called 'currency wars' are hotting up.

* And another: Australian financial conditions remain 'very accommodative'. The Aussie dollar has fallen relative to the US dollar, although not as far as commodity prices. We appear to still be a safe haven, though (ahem) the budget is in a right mess.

* 'Available data since the previous Statement suggest that the domestic economy continued to grow at a below-trend pace over the second half of 2014. Resource exports and dwelling investment have grown strongly. Consumption growth remains a bit below average. Growth of private non-mining business investment and public demand remain subdued, while mining investment has fallen further'.

* 'Housing price inflation has eased from the very rapid rates seen in late 2013, although it remains relatively high, particularly in Sydney and Melbourne'.

* Household consumption growth has picked up since early 2013, but is still below average, despite support from 'very low interest rates'.

* Various positive factors, increased wealth, etc, etc have been partially offset by 'weak growth in labour income, reflecting subdued conditions in the labour market'.

There we have it, dear readers. There is a lot of global uncertainty, with local political uncertainty to compound this,  but Henry must admit no strong case for the rate cut we received a week ago today.  This was well advertised in advance by a 'well connected' journo or two, and Henry reflects on how much things have changed since a few serior staff were authorised to take calls from the press when Bob Johnston took the reins. 

[As an aside, it is worth noting that properly trained economists believe that inside information makes a desirable contribution to creating a properly informed market. Why it is against the law is therefore one of those sweet mysteries of life, and presumably the current restrictive law will be changed as part of Josh Frydenberg's ongoing efforts to deregulate Australia's overregulated economy.]

But readers will be far more interested in why, with a weak rate cut case, and little warning, except via the trusties of the press, the deed was done.

There are three theories scudding about.

First, the economic outlook is worse than most people believe.  As I said in my pre-board briefing: 'Unless the RBA has joined the 'serious trouble' camp, its own stated position does not call for further rate cuts'.  But the degree of overt concern in the typically excellent RBA commentary summarised above does not support that theory.

Second, the fear might be, absent a rate cut (or two, or three), Australia will be a loser in the currency wars, the welcome fall in the Aussie dollar will stall and there will be no further improvement in competitiveness to pull the economy out of its current glide path. Again, while there are hints in this direction, it could be said that the near zero rate nations are in far worse shape that Australia, whose Treasurer keeps telling us the nation is in extremely good shape, and that the rate cuts will greatly improve the situation.

Third, in the absence of action to fix the budget, and improve efficiency and competitiveness, the RBA must do its bit to help. This might be seen as insurance in case an unhappy Treasurer begins to talk openly about removing Treasurer Costello's reform that made the RBA so much more effective, giving it a clear focus on 'goods and services inflation' and the power to act independantly in pursuit of that objective.

And it may be inflation - asset inflation rather than goods and services inflation - that is the main result of this rate cut and others anticipated by 'well connected' members of the press.

Perhaps we shall never know, except in the unlikely case Glenn Stevens uses his well-deserved retirement to write a blisteringly honest biography.  Perhaps the truth is there was a bit of all three arguments at play, and also Barnaby's full moon.

But the good news is the rate cut comes at a good time to illustrate Henry's editor's latest post-modern painting.

Read the full RBA statement here.

The first painting in the style of this is available here.

Sunday Sanity Break, 8 February 2015
Date: Sunday, February 08, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

'This dog will not run
'This boat will not float'
Ross Cameron, former Liberal backbencher, ahead of Party spill, now scheduled for 9 AM Monday.

'Tony has had absolute support from his senior colleagues. I will support him in any leadership spill'. Malcolm Turnbull, today.

As with the equivalent affirmation from Julie Bishop, 'this promise will not hold if a spill motion is passed'. The mob, to a man ... correction, person.

'Replace Joe Hockey as Treasurer by Malcolm Turnbull', Uncle Tom Cobley and many others in the past few days.  After all, it is the failed budget that is a main substantive weakness of Tony Abbott's performance in government.

'If Joe Hockey would agree to leave economic policy to Messrs Fraser and Stevens, at least until the current mess is sorted, I would vote for him to be given a second chance.  This is not a totally silly idea, dear readers. When a country gets so deep in the economic mire that it needs help from the International Monetary Fund, the tecnocrats get to call the shots.

'Far better to let our technocrats sort out the economy while there is still time to do so without advice from arrogant foreigners.  We've tried arrogant.  Let's have some genuine competence'. Henry Thornton, Friday 6 February.

So there you have it, dear readers. More political instability, following economic policy stasis amid assertion and counter assertion about which government is more responsible for the current mess. Greg Sheridan said among a blizzard of blame and analysis in the weekend press: ''... any government is now under constant attack from many of its own natural supporters, for not going far enough in the direction that alienates the majority of voters. There is a tremendous pincer movement of the extremes of your own base, louder than ever on social media, and the disgruntled in the centre and on the other side, louder than ever in their contradictory complaints'.

Paul Kelly, also yesterday, weighed in as follows. 'Rarely has the prime ministership seemed such a poisoned chalice. What is needed now, above all, is strong government. Yet resolute government is being put into grave jeopardy probably regardless of whether Abbott or Turnbull prevails.

'Two competing mantras echo across the partyroom. From Abbott: don’t surrender to chaos, weakness and Labor’s disease. And from the motley bunch of Turnbull travellers: seize this chance to save the government and invest it with new hope'.

More here, including a video.


This being a doldrum amongst the usual tempest of sporting news and views, the focus is on 'Leadership'. Leadership of Australia's world cup of cricket. Will Clarkie's hammy hold up? And if it does not, what about George Baily's form? And would Smithy lead the team if the hammy breaks again and George's form remains bad?

But there's more, dear readers. What about Watto's whatever? Is Johnno back to his scary best? Will Faulkner come up ok? If all the questions are answered in the affirmitive, Australia cannot lose.

In footy, the single biggest question is will Essendon be allowed to compete with all its players in 2015? Also: 'Will James Hird be leading them as coach? and 'Will Caaarlton! beat Essendon, even if the Dons are playing a hastily arranged team from Ascot Vale?

Great to see Timmy Cahill getting a fair suck of the sausage from the Shanghai dragons, and is also available to play for the Socceroos should the coach require him to do so. Go for it Ange.

Image of the week

Courtesy AFR

Political economy, Aussie style
Date: Friday, February 06, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

What to say about politics, Aussie style, as it relates to economic policy? Four Prime ministers in four years would be clearly excessive, because how are holders of that high office meant to learn how to perform well in such a difficult job? Of course it can be remarked the Prime minister's job is not for someone on work experience, but that is too glib. Every Prime minister learns a lot in his or her first term, which I suspect is a main reason that most Australian governments have been given at least a second term. But no, this is no longer the case, if the examples of Rudd'n'Gillard'n'Rudd, or of the hapless Campbell Newman, are any guide.

A friend suggested this is the result of addiction to smart phones. This addiction means many people just have to have the latest version, so whenever a new model appears they just have to have it. A scarier possibility is that people will just refuse to cop some sacrifices so that they are not stealing from their children and their children's children. Or perhaps Tony Abbott's brilliant attacks on Labor's leaders in government have established new standards for opposition leaders and he is reaping what he sowed. Yet demolition derby is no way to run a counry, and I at least remain confident that a more generous and more patriotic approach by oppositions will eventually repair politics and allow a more rational discourse about economic policy.

Maybe the situation will only be tackled when there is a real economic crisis, so real and so immediate that we can all understand it?

The government has, almost by definition, failed to establish a coherent narrative. At the start there was supposedly a 'budget emergency', really a looming debt trap.  Why did the Treasurer not establish some sensible budget projections as a matter of priority - both 'best guess' and 'realistic worst case'? Such projections would include the 'realistic worst case' in which commodity prices continued to fall relentlessly and with US recovery global interest rates would begin to rise. The 'realistic worst case' projections could have included 'loss of confidence in Australia's economic policy leading to an abrupt fall in the Australian dollar'. And jobs growth too weak to prevent the rate of unemployment from rising relentlessly.  Even if such assumptions were sneered at by the Labor opposition at the time as scaremongering, about now the government's 'realistic worst case' scenario would have shown the government to have been prudent.  Assuming of course that it had responded with policies designed to tackle the realistic worse case if such a future arrived.

Yet the hard graft of constructing 'realistic worst case' scenarios and debating them with cabinet and then the 'punters' - aka the voters - was not done. Instead the first coalition budget included very mild assumptions about the economy and the deficit.  It was celebrated by scenes of Joe Hockey and Mathias Cormann smoking big cigars on a porch in the parliamentary building. Conveying the totally inappropriate message of 'job done, problem fixed'. 'Its the end of the age of entitlement' said Smokin' Joe, 'cop our reforms and all will be well'.

There was of course a further glaring inconsistency in the coalition's narrative. Budget emergency but a generous paid parental leave scheme, the 'captain's pick' in economic policy. Deregulating university fees was a good policy that failed to engage the punters. Ditto Medicare copayment hike, if that is the right description. (Henry can hardly understand the current system, and never knows when to claim from Medicare and when to claim from the private healh fund, and consequently often fails to claim from either.  And hopes to be considered for a gong in the new category of 'taxpayer of the year'.) With other budget savings, the overall budget was instantly declared 'unfair' and there was no serious attempt to refute this pub and BBQ allegation. There was a good reason for this - the budget wasn't fair, and Australians will not cop unfair.

It is also unclear if the Treasurer has the desirable technical understanding.  Earlier this week he received the cut to cash rates as 'good news'. I suppose if it is regarded as a sign that he now realises just how bad the economic mess is that would be fine.  But he was more accurate whilst in opposition when he asserted the rate cuts were a sign of an economy in trouble. As I said in my latest advice on the matter, linked here, "unless the RBA has joined the 'serious trouble' camp, its own stated position does not call for further rate cuts".

If sketchy reports are accurate RBA chief Glenn Stevens and new Treasury Secretary John Fraser have given cabinet a far more realistic account of the state of the world and Australian economies, presumably based on current best guesses but also I hope with at least a tinge of 'realistic worst case'.  But I doubt that the same team lead by Smokin' Joe has the credibility to oversee the response.  Tony Abbott has said he will leave gongs to relevant officials in future.  If Joe Hockey would agree to leave economic policy to Messrs Fraser and Stevens, at least until the current mess is sorted, I would vote for him to be given a second chance.  This is not a totally silly idea, dear readers. When a country gets so deep in the economic mire that it needs help from the International Monetary Fund, the tecnocrats get to call the shots.

Far better to let our technocrats sort out the economy while there is still time to do so without advice from arrogant foreigners.  We've tried arrogant.  Let's have some genuine competance.

Henry's collected writings on economic policy over the past decade are available here.

Economic reform, not rate cuts
Date: Tuesday, February 03, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

Almost everyone involved in the debate about Australian economic policy is hyperventilating about what the RBA will do next. With every other country with zero or near zero cash rates, and all central banks of note but the US Fed buying bonds as part of the con job called 'quantitative easing', Glenn Stevens is being urged by some to cut local interest rates further.  The most defensible argument to this effect concerns alleged 'global deflation'.

Cutting rates here so far has been primarily because the economy was headed for bad times, a matter warned about here, for example.  There was also a belief that lower rates would help achieve a necessary faster fall in a clearly over-valued Aussie dollar.  But, as Glenn Stevens knows well, there are limits to what monetary policy can do.  In my view, Australia's economy is in deep trouble, but the RBA has been generally cheery about the immediate future. The Aussie dollar has fallen most of the way to US$0.75 and there are days when it seems likely to take a Swan dive.

Thus, unless the RBA has joined the 'serious trouble' camp, its own stated position does not call for further rate cuts.  Forecasts are for moderate income growth, gradually improving, Australia riding out the current 'income recession' caused by falling commodity prices as resources shift from mining to (for example) making coffees for hoardes of tourists.

Those economic commentators who are not totally focussed on monetary policy know what is needed:
* The budget needs to be fixed - and the knightood bestowed on Prince Philip is a negative item on that front as it givess recalcitrant Senators a fresh excuse not to support budget reform.
Australia's major cost disequilibrium needs to be overcome - and in the absence of Bob Hawke's gentle art of persuasion, this will only happen, and then gradually, by further falls in the Aussie dollar not compensated for by increases in wages and prices.  Further rate cuts will encourage wage and price hikes and work against the necessary correction.
* Economic reform, to boost Australia's productivity and international competitiveness, is required. Such action is also the major policy change required in the Eurozone, Japan, even the UK, where central banks are still using monetary policy in lieu of economic reform in futile attempts to restart the economic engines.

This 'Welcome to Country' for the new Secretary of Treasury provides a fair number of specific reforms for consideration, and the current discussion about reducing penalty rates for working on weekends and public holidays shows an appetite for reform in this vital area for creating new jobs. Yet internicene sniping evident within the government makes economic reform, always hard in any country, almost impossible.

Glenn Stevens has bravely told the government to get on with its job.  We endorse this carefully calculated advice and respectfully request the governor not to substitute unnecessay monetary easing for economic reform.

Saturday Sanity Break, 31 January 2015
Date: Saturday, January 31, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

The latest 'Captain's Pick' has shaken Australian politics. Henry has been a corporate captain and knows how vital it is to take one's fellow officers and indeed the noncoms and grunts with one.  One hopes lessons will (finally) be learned and there is no need for a garotting in a dark room, which was the unhappy result of odd activites by the Captain(s) in the last government. Clearly, however, this government needs far better communication with the grunts (Henry's readers, aka 'voters') as well as the noncoms and sub-captain officers. 

Do not miss Grace Collier's 'Am I a tosser' quiz in the Oz today. It beats all the criticism thrown at the PM by a country mile, proving yet again that satire's rapier beats serious broadsword work most of the time.

Then there is the Queensland election, which looks like going down to the wire. What a catastrophe for the Premier if he loses his seat and his party loses the election or, even worse for the Premier, his party scrambles back and he does not. The week's conspiracy theory is interesting.  The Federal government knows that Australian politics works best when state and Territory governments are different 'colors' to the Federal government.  Hence the ham-fisted attemps to 'help' the Victorian and Queensland conservatives lose the latest state elections. Here is our most recent analysis of this matter.


Two big bits of recent economic news:
* The European Central Bank (ECB) announced a massive bond-buying program ('Quantitative Easing', or 'QE')
* The US Fed, which some time ago ended its QE policy and the Dow soared despite the Federal Reserve clearly indicating that interest rates would soon move up.

The latest Raff Report says that the current business cycle in the U.S. only has 12 to 18 months and perhaps far less to run. To reiterate the current situation, U.S. Industrial Production lags new orders by 6 to 9 months and longer for some aircraft and other large capital items. On this basis, U.S. manufacturing should remain robust at least up until the end of 2015. In 2016 all bets are off. Chucking money at problems is like some aspects of farming. You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink. Ask the Japanese if this is not so.

Read the full Raff report here.

The Australian economy rumbles along despite the political gridlock and without the benefit of the new Treasury Secretary revealing his thoughts about the steaming pot he has inherited. Relatively high 'underlying' consumer inflation produced an upward twitch of the (still overvalued) currency and then with a majority of market denizens deciding the RBA will cut rates next week fell again.

Soon the Aussie will be in a danger zone in which a major slide will be likely.  While this might improve competitiveness, at least for a while, it would be far preferable if that could be achieved by economic reform.  But with the government in some strife this is about as likely as  peace in the Middle East, so we must grit our teeth and soldier on.

My regular advice to the board of the RBA is posted earlier than usual. Henry started the fashion of giving advice, or guessing outcomes, over a decade ago.  Now those who play this game start earlier and earlier, so we must comply, but with the RBA Board date on the relevant Blog.  Confused? You are not alone.

This edition starts with the proposition that our economic problems are not due to inappropriate monetary policy and that we need no further rate cuts.  But the people who think we do need further rate cuts earn far more than Henry, and readers should feel free to follow the money.

And, in the interests of 'balance', the very well connected Terry McCrann argues in the Oz today that the RBA's supposedly new plan for further rate cuts is because the world has changed, with deflation of goods and labor markets and new monetary expansion plans by the big guys, the US Fed apart, it is worth noting.


The courts have turned down James Hird's technical plea for redemption for the second time. But other expert opinion says that in the absence of ASADA's key witnesses their case against Essendon players has to fail.  If this occurs, all that will be left is a very nasty smell and a discredited football competition.

So far as Henry understands, there is no hard evidence, of the sort that is produced by regular drug testing.  Perhaps the issue is like racing on bikes in the Lance Franklin era.  We all suspect the presence of 'enhanced' players, even teams, but it may take death-bed confessions in 50 years to be sure.

Meanwhile, footy's main rival for hearts and minds, 'Futball', or 'Soccer', has produced a magnificant Asian Cup and the Socceroos are set to play South Korea in the final tonight.  After the brilliant wins over China and the UAE, including four brilliant goals Henry is warming to 'futball' as never before.

The tennis has been exciting and it all comes to an end this weekend. Nrws that Lleyton is finally retiring in a year or so is comforting and his continuing involvement in the Davis cup is further good news.  It's time we got competitive in that competition, Lleyton, and the promising crop of brilliant young players will make it possible.  Do not overlook that former Vermont football player, as he has the spirit and physical strength to become an intimidating force if he works hard enough.

'Stuff' this week is focussed on government, as is today's Image of the Week, courtesy AFR and the brilliant David Rowe.

Image of the Week

Saturday Sanity Break, 24 January 2015
Date: Saturday, January 24, 2015
Author: Henry Thornton

Happy Oz Day weekend, gentle readers. we hope it all goes swimmingly, and those who deserve Oz Day honours get their just desserts.

Mario Draghi has finally found the courage to buy bonds with printed Euros, introducing 'Quantitative Easing' (QE) to the Eurozone.  The USA, the UK and Japan are all ahead in that game, and all for the same reason, that conventional easy money has failed to stimulate goods and labor markets. Curiously, no-one seems to acknowledge that 'QE' has massively stimulated asset markets, making owners of assets richer, while doing very little to help battlers.

The real issue for economists is to explain why very easy monetary policy has failed to stimulate goods and labor markets. In seeking to understand this issue, economists would be wise to delve into the history of English monetary policy.  In 1871, The Economist reported, fairly offhand, as follows: ‘On several occasions like the present, the Bank of England has borrowed largely on Consols – and in this way circumvented lack of market rate response to the lower discount rate'.  To me this is a description of 'QE', attributed to the grand Old Lady of global monetary policy.

Anyway, with the partial exception of the mighty USA, zero discount rates and QE seem utterly impotant.  To a simple bloke like Henry, this suggests that easy money, even very easy money, is not the core reason for sluggish goods and labor markets. Governments are like the drunk looking for his wallet under the lamp post, not because that's where he lost it, but because that's where the light is best.

The Oz reports that Tony Abbott has had his 'Banana Republic' moment, warning that Australia risks becoming a 'second rate' nation. That's a good start, but the Treasurer earlier in the new year was spreading optimism about the state of the nation.  The only way to square the circle here is that Mr Hockey is confident he can successfully fix the budget mess, and the large-scale cost disequilibrium and restore Australia's productive growth and global competitiveness. 

Henry has advised the incoming Treasury Secretary on the questions he, (and the Treasurer), should be asking. Just as 'Disunity is Death', failure to 'Ask the right questions' is a second certain way to fail, in economic management as much as anything. In effect, Australia has a mild version of the Eurozone disease, sluggish growth of goods and labor markets, and Treasury and the RBA will be (or should be) delving into history and current experience of other nations to find the answers.

In case you missed them, Mr Hockey, here are the questions and a set of implied answers.


Very sad to see the exit of Lleyton Hewitt and Sam Stouser from the Oz Open, but great performances by the younguns, lead by Bernard Tomic and Nick Kyrgios, made for a cheery start to the weekend.

We think we heard that the ugly Oz cricketers beat the Poms with the second last ball of their innings, which is about as good as beating Collingwood by one point kicked after the siren due to an umpiring error.

But the highlight of the sporting week was undoubtedly the wonderful win by the Socceroos over the brave Chinese team in the quarter final of the Asian Cup of Futball.  And the goals scored by Tim Cahill were a joy to behold - here is a replay.


Henry was awakened at 7 AM today by a discussion on Radio National with the author of what sounds like a very nice book about the state of play in Australian culture. Will try to find a link, but this bloke  - a BBC correspondant - sounded like he is onto something.  Some overlap with the fin's interview of Anna Funder, linked here. We used to cut down the tall poppies, but 'now we are cutting the cultural cringe'. (AFR P 18, no link I can find.)

Also in the fin, nice discussion of the need to take science mosr seriously, with the views of Australia's four living Nobel laureates.

American Sniper is a must see movie in what is a summer of movie excellence.  Here is a link to the trailor and additional critical comment by Grace Randolph.

Also nice review in the Fin (P 51).

Image of the week

« PREVIOUS   | ... 4| 5| 6| 7| 8| [9] | 10| 11| 12| 13| 14| ... |   NEXT »
For member services:
Forgot Password?
MacroBusiness Blog »
MacroBusiness Blog
The Australian »
The Australian
Quadrant »

Other sites we like »
Membership to
is FREE and the benefits, are overwhelming!
ONLY AUD $55.00 pa
Show your real colours and signup as a
proud, card carrying friend of Henry
HOME | NEWS + Views | Economics | Politics | Investments | Corporate | SMERSH | Lifestyle | FORUM | SIGN UP
Sydney web design by Sydney web design by Wiliam web developer
© 2009. henrythornton.com Pty Limited. All Rights Reserved. The Herald Tribune is powered by the New York Times.